You are viewing page 1 of 41.

Hard Disk Problems

By Timothy R Butler | Posted at 4:45 AM

Well, after spending some time last month helping my pastor with his dying hard disk, it seems I caught the same bug, so to speak. Early last week, my PowerMac G5 started to emit an odd sound — I ignored it at first. Then on Friday, I noticed that my hard disk was a lot noisier during drive access than before. Shortly thereafter, Mac OS X crashed — one of the only times it has ever done so. Taking note of this, I called AppleCare on Saturday, went through a bunch of tests, but came up with no problems on the drive.

Given that it was continuing to emit noises, I decided to go with my gut and buy another drive to back the whole thing up to. I purchased the newer variant of the same drive (both the new and old drives are Seagate 160 GB 7200 RPM SATA disks, but the newer one supports “NCQ”), installed it quickly, thanks to the effortless and tool-less hard disk install procedure that Apple engineered, and then used CarbonCopy Cloner to make a perfect copy of my old drive. Less than two hours after I opened the box for the new drive, I was running OS X and all of my applications on the new disc, with the old one relegated to backup status. The majority of that time was waiting for files to copy; it took 89 minutes to clone 70 GB of data from the old drive to the new one.

Still, I need to figure out a way to prove to AppleCare that something is fishy with the old drive. Today, the system froze twice, each time when I tried to do something fairly intensive with the old hard disk. This is unusual for OS X, which is as stable as you'd expect a BSD Unix to be, that is, rock solid. Since the drive is under warranty for another year and a half, perhaps I just need to wait for it to die completely or do something that will allow diagnostics to detect the problem, but I'd really rather have them send me a new drive now so that I can trust what has become my backup drive. If I can convince them to do so, I'd have two reliable hard disks, allowing for redundancy.

Rant: Social Contracts and the Web

By Timothy R Butler | Posted at 2:46 AM
If you use this tool, be aware of a sensitive issue. Although you may feel that your enjoyment of some Web sites is marred by the presence of ads, these ads represent a revenue stream for the Web site. If you block ads, there are those who would assert you are not holding up your end of a “social contract” between yourself and the Web site that you are browsing.
—Chris Lynch, NewsForge

I saw this on Slashdot today. Here is someone that gets the web advertising situation perfectly. While many people are oblivious to it, much as they are other ethical situations, there is an unspoken “social contract” to viewing web sites. If you view my site and it has ads on it, it does not require a serious ethical consideration to understand that a barter situation is going on under the honor system, and the honorable thing to do is to download the ads.

As I have said before, in most cases, the person viewing a site has unmetered access and the person providing the site does not. Therefore, when you download an ad, it costs you time, but when you view my site, it costs me money. And it still costs me money when you do not view my ads. If we were dealing with any situation other than web site viewing, I really doubt someone would feel it was ethical to not uphold their part of the bargain despite the fact that they were materially costing the other party. And TiVo analogies do not hold water: NBC is not materially impacted in any way when I watch a show like Revelations. While it still may be right to view the ads, they do not have to amplify their signal more because I am tuning in; therefore, the web developer's situation is much more like that of a shopkeeper selling goods than the television network broadcasting a show.

I continue to insist that the moral thing to do if you do not like the ads on a site is to quit viewing that site. It is simple and ethical. If I don't like how much the grocery store charges for an apple, I do not steal the apple, I go somewhere else to buy apples. Likewise, web surfers should examine the cost of a given site and then choose whether to “shop” there or elsewhere, not give themselves a five finger discount because it is easier than “driving to the other store.” Remember: if everyone did that…

A frequent argument is that the web was fine without commercialized sites. Perhaps it was. Those who feel that way should simply refuse to use commercialized sites rather than trying to force commercialized sites to become non-commercial by raiding and pillaging them. Nothing is stopping users from ignoring the boom of sites that have appeared thanks to advertising revenue.

And that, my friends, ends my rant of the night.

Idiotic

By Timothy R Butler | Posted at 1:14 AM

My Case Again Ad Blocking for Ethical Reasons
Written February 13-16, 2005

Just to elaborate a bit more, since you seem interested and I am glad to provide the view from the other side. My main point I like to make is that I too am paying for bandwidth (quite a bit, actually!). If you block the ads, you are taking everything and giving nothing in return. I make nothing off the fact that you pay your ISP money — just like an musician makes nothing off the fact that you pay your ISP to download their music off of a P2P site. A better analogy, perhaps: if you pay money to go into a theme park and then take some small craft vendor's product without paying for it, will that vendor be comforted by the fact that you had to pay to get in and take their product? Probably not, because, just like you, they pay to be in the park with the hope that you will buy their product.

Anyway, while the end user is usually on an unmetered plan, my bandwidth is metered and will cost more if I use up my quota. To the tune of $1-$2 per GB, which can add up fast. If you allow the ads to come through, I take some form of “payment” and you take some “product” and we both come out (hopefully) ahead. I'm all for advocating blocking popups, since they invade your screen rather than staying within the page you requested, but if I trusted government more, I'd push to make general ad blocking illegal, since that is only a little site vendor placing a way of recooping costs on the page you requested.

I've considered setting things up so that my sites would refuse to work if ads were blocked with the option of paying with cash as an alternative. I've never gotten that far, though. I think it would serve its purpose though: few people would want to pay money to read my site, they'd probably much rather ignore my ad banners. Just think, if everyone blocked ads, every site would either have to be non-commercial or subscriber only, which would severely limit what we could find on the Internet without a giant bank account.

As an aside, when people complain about ads, I often encourage the use of Lynx or elinks. Since a text based browser uses less of my bandwidth when visiting my site, less harm is done than if people come and load all the “pretty stuff” but block the only thing that generates the profit that keeps the site going.

Well, anyway, I don't mean to keep going on about this. As you can tell, I've thought a lot about this over the years (I've been serving ads on my sites since 1997). :-)

[…]

Now, to confirm what Ed said, the hit count is totally disconnected from revenue (although a high hit count might make you look interesting to advertisers that figure you must have something good to say). There are two types of major ads — CPM and CPC. CPM is cost per impressions, where I am paid for each ad viewed as in downloaded. Most ad blockers block the ad from being downloaded, therefore I am not paid anything. Then there are the CPC's, which have come to be the advert of choice, and of which I only get paid if you click on the ad. Therefore, in both cases, the ad blocking tools do deprive the site owner of revenue (unlike the similar situation on TV).

The other thing to remember is that since click throughs can be measured quite easily (in fact, every one is counted even on CPM ads), advertisers will notice if a site doesn't provide good click through results, even if an ad blocker was kind enough to download the ad prior to removing it from the page.

[…]

Personally, what I would like to see is a consortium of major ad networks get together and offer a “network wide” service that spans all of their networks. In this system, I could pay a certain dollar amount to avoid seeing so many ads on any network site.

Most people, I believe, given proper education of how revenue is generated from ads (i.e. that ad blocking does indeed stop revenue) and this choice to pay to opt out, would choose to keep viewing ads. I would. But some people hate ads enough that it might be worth $20 extra month not to see any ads.

Personally, I don't mind ads on a page that much. I do block popups/popunders and refuse to carry them on my sites as a matter of principle. I see those as invading the user's computer, even if they don't install adware. But, I don't mind having ads pop up on the sites I use otherwise.

[…]

Back in the day, the internet was free and text based. It can still be free and text based with a browser such as lynx. Lynx never loads the ads, but as I noted, it also doesn't load any other graphics, keeping my bandwidth bill down. :-)

How Very Tempting

By Timothy R Butler | Posted at 12:41 AM

I went over to 1&1 today to take care of some domain business (I've been using them for awhile, since their registration fee is just $6/year), and happened to look at their present deals for dedicated servers. Their deals are really getting sweet. For $89 you get a P4 2.4 GHz system (or better) with the ability to reimage the server if anything goes wrong, a serial console in case the network interface goes down, enough NAS backup space to backup the entire 80 gig hard disk, Plesk 7 Reloaded, an SSL cert and external firewall protection.

I'll tell you, it is tempting to contemplate moving over there from ServerMatrix/The Planet. I'm paying much more than that for a slower machine with fewer features. I'm not going to, because the Planet has serious support, provides some management services and a very clear way of specifying what to do in case of server failure. I also get RHEL out of the deal, which means the system has enterprise grade stable updates, rather than bleeding edge ones (1&1 uses Fedora Core 2).

I could lower my hosting prices if I went with this, and perhaps even turn a profit on hosting rather than breaking even, but it isn't worth it. When I had a shared hosting account, I opted for a more expensive provider that was better backed, and I hope to provide the same thing to my clients (and of course, myself). That's not to say I went with the most expensive provider, I've just always been suspicious of the deep-discounting hosts.

Still, if anyone signs up for a 1&1 server, I'd love to hear about your experiences.

Internet Problems?

By Timothy R Butler | Posted at 3:30 AM

Anyone else having trouble getting to sites on the Internet? Google seems to be inaccessible, as does Barnes and Noble and Apple, among others. I can get to my site, SCF and Amazon. Interesting.

Update (2005.03.14 22:06): Everything appears to be up again. Yay!

(Grumble) AudioScrobber (Grumble)

By Timothy R Butler | Posted at 5:30 AM

Josiah turned me on to AudioScrobber, which tracks what music you play for the purpose of recommending songs as well as comparing common musical themes between members of AudioScrobber groups (for instance, Josiah started one named after his blog).

The problem is that its update application leaves some functionality to be desired. It isn't a plugin to iTunes, it runs constantly in the background instead, watching for when the Recently Played playlist is updated in iTunes. Not quite comfortable making it an auto-start application until I used it for awhile, I started it manually. Shortly thereafter, I was away from my desktop for ten days, during which time I did not synchronize my iPod (I don't synchronize it with my laptop).

Tonight I plugged it in, forgetting that I had restarted my desktop (and therefore needed to restart AudioScrobber's tool) and therefore despite the fact that I had listened to a lot of music during the evenings the past two weeks, none of it will show up on my statistics page. Since some of the stats are only produced once a week, I'll wait another week before linking to my page on the site, since the stats still aren't that useful (grumble) unlike how they would have been if the app had just been a plugin and therefore would have caught my iPod sync.

Google Maps Now for Safari

By Timothy R Butler | Posted at 3:56 AM

Google seems to have finally made Maps available for Safari, which is a real treat. It seems very user friendly and I like the fact that you can drag maps around and zoom in/out without having to wait for the page to reload. The only thing they could do to improve it is make a way to point out to the program if it gives you a route you do not want to take. I was trying it out, and it seemed to like going through various crime ridden areas to get there rather than taking the freeway. Sure, I like to save two minutes as much as the next guy, but it is not always worth it.

102.

By Timothy R Butler | Posted at 4:40 AM

That's the number of brute force attempts on Cedar since November. It is depressing to think that so many people have tried enough to set the alarm off. There are, of course, many more that tried only a few times. Like e-mail spam and blog spam, all of this seems to be done by bots; if the number of bots continues to increase at its alarming rate, it seems inevitable that the house of cards will fall… it is just a matter of when.

Hmm... Can Napster Last?

By Timothy R Butler | Posted at 6:06 AM

Someone with too much time on their hands, decided to figure out exactly how much music they could get off Napster's new Napster to Go service, convert to WAV files and burn to CD's within the free trial period. Their calculations allow for the creation of 250+ CD's during that 14 day period. Of course, Napster To Go isn't suppose to allow burning, but the folks planning this simply did the same thing I did when I wanted to record a live audio stream a few years back — capture the audio stream and save it as WAV files.

Obviously, for those who'll abuse this service, this makes Napster To Go a much better value than iTunes Music Store, since you can't steal 250 CD's worth of music from iTMS. In the long run, however, I suspect that this might spell the end of Napster. If word about this gets around, the service will be abused and the record labels will get quite angry about people downloading thousands of songs and keeping them forever with an investment worth about one CD ($14.95).

I'm actually glad about this in a way, though. This means Microsoft PlayForSure Janus subscriber technology may be defeated before it becomes popular. Anything that keeps RIAA from making it so people don't even have a permanent copy of the music they pay for is a good thing for everyone else.

(Not that I advocate signing up for Napster to steal music off of it, I simply like the idea that maybe this will throw a wrench in a bad idea whose time has not come.)

Oligopoly Versus Monopoly for the Future

By Timothy R Butler | Posted at 1:19 AM

For the moment, neither Apple nor Microsoft are in any position to exercise anti-competitive behavior (the only part of being a monopoly that is illegal), simply because digital music is still a minute chunk of the market. But, both companies are behaving the way they usually do, so we can pretty much guess what things will be like once digital downloads become the dominate form of distribution by analyzing the two companies' track records.

Apple is a vertical kind of company. They create as much as possible in house so that it works in a simple and elegant fashion. You'll pay a bit more and you shouldn't wait for compatible clones, they ain't happing. That isn't the Apple way. This is the same as many other segments of the industry — for instance, the electronic gaming industry, where you would never expect a Nintendo Gamecube to be able to run Sony PlayStation 2 software. You could probably expect a lawsuit to occur if Nintendo even tried, just as Sony sued Connectix in the late nineties for making a Virtual PlayStation. And that's perfectly reasonable and legal.

Microsoft has a very different approach, partially because Microsoft is only a software company (normally, at least), unlike Apple, who has always been mostly a hardware company. Microsoft has always sought to open the hardware portion of the business up, because they aren't in that business. Yet, Microsoft is the company that has violated the Sherman Anti-Trust Act, quite likely for a reason that is lost on no one: they do not make the hardware, but by establishing a firm software monopoly, they have essentially taken all but a facade of control away from individual hardware makers. HP, Dell, Gateway and others who are beholden to Microsoft cannot afford to make Microsoft mad, lest they be cut out of volume discounts and development partnerships. This is true, even in the post-DOJ v. Microsoft world.

How does this factor into music? It factors in perfectly. Apple has chosen to keep FairPlay close to home, licensing it only to a fellow member of the PowerPC AIM trio (Apple/IBM/Motorola). Apple did, apparently, also approach Sony last year, only to be turned down, but essentially, Apple doesn't license stuff. The closest you'll likely see, I believe, would be more HP-like deals where Apple will co-brand iPods like PalmOne did in the past with Palm PDA's. Apple never tries to hide this. Microsoft, on the other hand, is on track to create the same kind of abusive monopoly in media players that they have in computers — all they have to do is topple the Apple iPod phenomenon. Think about it. Try to name one major media player, other than the iPod, that doesn't use Microsoft technology. You won't think of one, save for the dismal failure that is the Sony MP3 player.

That's right. Part of your purchase price for a Creative NuVo, Rio, Dell DJ, RCA Lyra, iRiver, etc. goes back to Redmond as licensing for Windows Media support, now known as PlayForSure. Likewise, think of online stores and try to name just one that uses something other than Windows Media, save for iTMS and Sony's store. This is very important. Microsoft has essentially secured control of both sides of the equation just like Apple has done with the iPod/iTMS, only there remains a facade of competition that will become increasingly hollow, presuming Microsoft manages to secure a majority share of the market.

Given that Apple seeks only to control its own platform, and not everyone else's, we can be confident, I believe, that even if the iPod remains the dominate player, Apple will never secure a real monopoly, simply because the iPod will not be the best player for every single person. However, Microsoft's plan allows for a very real ability to create another abusive monopoly, since Microsoft seeks to play the role of puppet master rather than actor on the stage of multimedia.

The media player war is only the beginning. Both Apple and Microsoft are trying hard to get their competing formats accepted as part of the next generation DVD standard. Whomever holds this will likely be given easy passage to dominance in the majority of multimedia on TV, the computer and elsewhere. While a win for Microsoft will usher in an era of the proprietary Windows Media Format, Apple's entry is only partially proprietary. It is true that the PlayFair DRM is proprietary, but AAC, the format of iTMS, is based on the open standard MPEG-4. In fact, the parts of QuickTime that Apple is advocating for DVD playing are also components of MPEG-4. What Apple has done with media formats is much like what it has done with Mac OS X. It has a proprietary element, but Apple has also willingly used an open foundation in both cases (MPEG-4 and the now FSF-approved APSL-licensed Darwin, respectively).

So, which is worse? An oligopoly where Apple controls its portion of the market, but is never dominate and even uses open standards as its foundation, or a competitively facaded monopoly dominated by Microsoft (and the companies beholden to the same) as one prong in its Trusted Computing Initiative?

You are viewing page 1 of 41.